Welcome back to the Rookie Report! Week 3 was another wild one in the NFL that continued to see depressed offensive outputs. Scoring for the first 3 weeks is down more than 2 points per game per team from last season. Maybe it’s because of all the high-end offensive personnel movement last offseason, maybe it’s because of officials letting DBs get away with more physical play, but no matter the reason I think all of us are ready to never have to watch another 11-10 game in primetime again.

Many of the rookies continued strong starts to their seasons. Breece Hall, Chris Olave, Drake London, and Romeo Doubs were the stars of week 3, with Jahan Dotson and Garrett Wilson coming back down to earth a bit. Week 4 should be full of riveting matchups. Only 3 games this week opened with a point spread of more than 3.5 points. It should make for some tough lineup decisions in your fantasy leagues, but luckily, I’m here to help you sort through the rookies again!

A couple of housekeeping notes for the players listed below – All players listed under the same header at the same position are listed in the order that I would play them this week, and all references to fantasy points and points allowed rankings are based on half-PPR scoring unless otherwise noted. Any data on route participation, air yards, and other usage rates are per Dwain McFarland’s Utilization Report on Pro Football Focus.

Let’s get into week 4…

Rookies You Already Know You Should Start:

WR Chris Olave, NO (Wk. 4: vs. Min.): Olave has earned 13 targets in each of the last 2 weeks, and both Michael Thomas and Jarvis Landry are battling injuries that could keep them out or limit them in week 4. The Vikings rank just 20^th in Football Outsiders’ pass defense DVOA and have allowed the 14^th-most WR points per game. This isn’t a matchup to be afraid of, and Olave is quickly establishing himself as the best receiver in this offense. You shouldn’t be sitting him in what could be another big day for the youngster.

WR Drake London, ATL (Wk. 4: vs. Cle.): London took a back seat in target share to Kyle Pitts for the first time this season in week 3, and he still found the end zone and finished the week as a WR3. The Browns have allowed the 10^th-most WR points per game, and while they had some success slowing opposing WR1s in DJ Moore and Elijah Moore, they allowed 8-84 on 11 targets last week to Diontae Johnson. Don’t let Denzel Ward scare you off starting London this week. He should be a WR3 or better again.

Borderline Rookies I’d Lean Toward Starting:

RB Breece Hall, NYJ (Wk. 4: @Pit.): Hall out-snapped Michael Carter for the first time in week 3, and he saw double-digit targets for the second time this season. He’s been a double-digit PPR scorer in all 3 games so far, his playing time continues to grow each week, and this week he faces a Pittsburgh defense that has allowed the 6^th-most RB points per game. It all adds up to Hall being a slam dunk RB2 this week, but there is a least some risk to consider with Zach Wilson returning to play quarterback. Since the start of last season, we’ve seen running backs fare better as receivers with Mike White and Joe Flacco under center than with Zach Wilson, and more than 70% of Breece Hall’s PPR points this year have come from receiving production. I still like Hall here as a high-end RB3, but this is an important game to monitor to see if it’ll be the same old Zach Wilson we saw in 2021.

WR Garrett Wilson, NYJ (Wk. 4: @Pit.): There’s risk here for Wilson as the Jets adjust back to Zach Wilson under center for week 4. They may not throw the ball as much as they have in previous weeks (averaging an absurd 52 attempts per game so far) and have an implied total of just 18.5 points this week. I’m betting on the talent to win out for Wilson in a matchup that the numbers say is better than you might’ve guessed. Pittsburgh hasn’t given up a ton of real points, but they’ve allowed the 8^th-most fantasy points per game to wideouts including 5 different double-digit scoring outputs through 3 games. Wilson has shown he can command targets, and this is a matchup where targets should lead to fantasy points. He’s an upside WR3 with a little lower floor than usual this week.

WR Treylon Burks, TEN (Wk. 4: @Ind.): In weeks 1 and 2, Burks played limited snaps but was heavily targeted whenever he was on the field. His route participate rate was under 60% but he was targeted on at least 35% of his routes in each game. In week 3, that sort of reversed as his route participation jumped to 97% but his target rate dropped to just 9%. He was in a route on almost every pass play but was targeted just twice. I expect those numbers to meet somewhere in the middle in week 4. Most of Burks’ spike in playing time in week 3 came at the expense Austin Hooper and the injured Kyle Philips. Philips is practicing this week in a limited capacity and should be able to return to the lineup, but Burks has likely supplanted him as the WR3. Treylon probably loses some snaps to his fellow rookie this week, but he should still be on the field a lot, and I expect the Titans to once again make it a point to get him heavily involved. I’d set his floor at 5-6 targets against a Colts’ defense that ranks 27^th in pass defense DVOA. Burks is a volatile WR3 this week.

Borderline Rookies I’d Lean Toward Sitting:

RB Dameon Pierce, HOU (Wk. 4: vs. LAC): This week’s matchup for Pierce is something of a catch-22 for the rookie back. The Chargers have been shredded on the ground to the tune of 5.3 yards per carry through the first 3 weeks. They’ve given up the 5^th-most RB points per game. This is typically the kind of matchup you want to attack with a running back like Pierce who does most of his damage on the ground. The problem is that the Chargers boast an explosive offense that put the Texans in a very negative game script and render Pierce’s rushing ability moot. LA’s offense struggled against a better-than-expected Jaguars defense a week ago with Justin Herbert not at 100% due to a rib injury, but I don’t expect them to have the same issues getting going against the Texans. If you believe the Texans can hang with the Chargers on Sunday, Pierce could be a fine RB2. If they play from multiple scores behind all day like I expect, we’re going to see more Rex Burkhead than we want and Pierce becomes a dicey flex option.

RB Kenneth Walker III, SEA (Wk. 4: @Det.): The Lions are typically a matchup to target with running backs, ranking 31^st in run defense DVOA and allowing the most RB points per game, but Walker’s role remains too small to trust in fantasy lineups. Walker handled just 13% of the team rushing attempts in week 3, and Travis Homer and DeeJay Dallas still play the overwhelming majority of passing down snaps. Walker is a long shot to provide fantasy value this week unless game script heavily favors the Seahawks. Seattle is a 5-point underdog.

RB Tyler Allgeier, ATL (Wk. 4: vs. Cle.): The Browns don’t represent a daunting matchup for Allgeier, ranking just 26^th in run defense DVOA, but Tyler is playing only about a third of offensive snaps and isn’t getting any receiving work. He has a chance to see his value increase later in the season if Cordarrelle Patterson gets hurt or wears down like he did last year, but for now you can’t count on more than 6-8 touches for Allgeier. That’s not enough work to trust him in your lineups.

RB Jaylen Warren, PIT (Wk. 4: vs. NYJ): You probably already know to sit Warren, but if you saw his touches on Thursday Night Football you might’ve been impressed enough to get some ideas about what he could do against a bad Jets’ defense. The Jets rank 26^th in run defense DVOA and have allowed the 7^th-most RB points per game, and this is one of the few games where Pittsburgh could have garbage time with a lead this season. That adds up to Warren being a sneaky play this week, especially in DFS, but his offensive snaps have decreased each week this season. He played a season-low 12 snaps last week, which just isn’t enough work to trust him in fantasy lineups.

WR Jahan Dotson, WAS (Wk. 4: @Dal.): The Washington passing attack that looked so dynamic in the first two weeks came crashing down to earth in week 3 against the Eagles. Carson Wentz still ended up with over 200 passing yards, but 83% of his yardage came on the last 3 drives of the game with Washington in a big hole. The biggest issue for the passing game was protecting Wentz from Philly’s pass rush. Philly generated pressure on 40% of Wentz’s dropbacks and sacked the QB 9 times (insert Ferris Bueller ‘Nine times’ reference here). This week the Commanders could face similar issues against a Dallas defense that is fresh off generating 5 sacks of Daniel Jones and a 45% pressure rate on Monday night. Dotson and teammate Terry McLaurin do their best work downfield. Both have an average target depth more than 13 yards downfield, and those kinds of longer throws won’t have time to develop if the Commanders can’t protect Wentz again. Look for a lot of dump offs to Curtis Samuel and JD McKissic once again. That duo accounted for 52% of the Commanders’ receptions last week. Wentz did try to get the ball to Dotson last Sunday, targeting him 8 times, but they were rarely able to connect as Dotson finished with 2 catches for 10 yards. I’d be hesitant to trust Dotson as anything more than a WR4 this week.

WR Romeo Doubs, GB (Wk. 4: vs. NE): It hasn’t taken long for Doubs to assert himself as the potential WR1 in the Packers’ offense. There were other receivers sidelined last week (Christian Watson & Sammy Watkins), opening opportunity for Doubs to be a nearly every down player, and he made the most of the opportunity. Doubs was in a route for 95% of Aaron Rodgers dropbacks, and he turned 8 targets into an 8-73-1 line. Watson and Watkins are both likely to return this week, so Doubs should see his playing time come back down to earth a bit, but he has consistently made an impact whenever he’s gotten the chance to do so. The Packers would be wise to keep giving him chances. The matchup this week isn’t a great one. The Patriots have allowed the 5^th-fewest WR points per game, and the 8^th-most running back receiving yards. They are more vulnerable to Aaron Jones and AJ Dillon through the air than the WR group. Doubs still has upside here, but I wouldn’t count on much more than 40-50 yards for the rookie.

WR George Pickens, PIT (Wk. 4: vs. NYJ): Pickens made arguably the catch of the season last Thursday night against the Browns, but his overall fortunes remain the same as they did going into that game. He’s running a lot of routes that help create space underneath for his teammates, but Mitch Trubisky is struggling to get Pickens the ball, even when coverage dictates that he should. Trubisky did at least attempt more passes in George’s direction in week 3, but outside of the dazzling circus catch he made Pickens totaled 2 catches for 3 yards on 6 targets. The Jets are a favorable matchup here, allowing the 11^th-most WR points per game, but I just don’t trust Trubisky to connect with Pickens enough to amount to a worthwhile fantasy day. Perhaps you can cross your fingers and hope that Trubisky gets benched for Kenny Pickett mid-game. Fantasy football aside, the matchup between Pickens and opposing rookie cornerback Sauce Gardner should be a fun one to watch.

TE Daniel Bellinger, NYG (Wk. 4: vs. Chi.): You may not think of Bellinger as a borderline option, but he is the unquestioned starting tight end for the Giants and he finally started seeing targets come his way on Monday night, turning in a 4-40 line on 5 targets against the Cowboys. New York is running short on wide receivers after the season-ending injury to Sterling Shepard, so there may be upside for a healthy target share for Bellinger, but the Bears have only given up 5 points or more (half-PPR) to one tight end in the first 3 weeks. I’d steer clear of Bellinger unless you’re desperate.

Rookies You Already Know You Should Sit:

QB Bailey Zappe, NE (Wk. 4: @GB): Mac Jones suffered a high ankle sprain that will put him on the shelf for a few weeks late in New England’s loss to the Ravens on Sunday, but Joe Judge essentially confirmed this week that it’ll be Axel Brian Hoyer who will take over in his absence (Yes, his real first name is Axel!). Zappe only needs an injury or some poor performance from Hoyer to see playing time, but he’s no more than a stash in deep 2-QB leagues for now.

RB Rachaad White, TB (Wk. 4: vs. KC): White’s playing time and touches have decreased each week of the season so far. This is Lenny’s backfield for the foreseeable future. It’s possible White plays more in week 4 than he has in the last couple weeks, but I don’t want to count on that in fantasy lineups.

RB Isiah Pacheco, KC (Wk. 4: @TB): The Chiefs have played two competitive games in the first 3 weeks of the season, and Pacheco has totaled 10 offensive snaps and 5 touches in those two games. Kansas City should be in another tight game this week. They’re favored by less than a field goal, and the Bucs have allowed the fewest running back points per game in the league so far.

RB James Cook, BUF (Wk. 4: @Bal.): Cook’s best opportunities to put up fantasy production are going to come in garbage time, and it’s hard to count on that this week in what should be one of the best games of the week. He’ll see some change-of-pace receiving work as well, but not enough to warrant fantasy consideration unless you’re desperate. Cook played just 11 snaps in week 3.

RB Jordan Mason, SF (Wk. 4: vs. LAR): Mason played just 5 snaps and carried just once on Sunday night despite having only Jeff Wilson Jr. ahead of him on the depth chart. Deebo Samuel is the RB2 right now in this offense. Mason may need an injury to Wilson to have any meaningful fantasy value in the coming weeks.

WR Kyle Philips, TEN (Wk. 4: @Ind.): Philips may return to action this week, and while it could throw a wrench into the Titans’ WR rotation against the Colts, it’ll be hard to trust him in Indy. The Colts have allowed the 3^rd-fewest PPR points to opposing wide receivers lined up in the slot and Philips spends nearly two-thirds of his snaps lined up there.

WR Christian Watson, GB (Wk. 4: vs. NE): Watson was a full participant in practice this week and should be good to return, but he didn’t seem to have much of a role in week 2 with Allen Lazard back on the field. Watson ran a route on just 27% of the passing dropbacks in that game before missing week 3 with a hamstring issue. Romeo Doubs’ emergence last week makes it even more of a long shot for Watson to establish himself against New England. Watson’s best hope is to break a big play, and New England has allowed just 3 completions of more than 25 yards this season.

WR David Bell, CLE (Wk. 4: @Atl.): Bell’s playing time ticked up in week 3, but the passing volume remains too volatile week-to-week to trust any WR beyond Amari Cooper. Bell has seen just two total targets come his way this season.

WR Skyy Moore, KC (Wk. 4: @TB): Chiefs’ offensive coordinator Eric Bieniemy guaranteed last week that Skyy Moore would play more than two snaps in week 3, and while 8 offensive snaps are technically more than 2, it’s not the step forward any of us had in mind for him. The problem was that Moore’s week got derailed before it got started when he muffed the first punt of the game, and it got even worse when he was tentative on the next punt and allowed the Colts to pin the Chiefs against their own goal line. I do think we will see Skyy’s snaps start to tick up going forward, but I’m not comfortable considering him for lineups until we see that playing time increase happen.

WR Jalen Tolbert, DAL (Wk. 4: vs. Was.): The Commanders have allowed the 3^rd-most WR points so far this year, but Tolbert isn’t the Dallas WR who will benefit from the favorable matchup. Tolbert was active for the first time Monday night, and he totaled just 1 catch for 4 yards on 2 targets. Michael Gallup is likely to return to action this weekend.

TE Isaiah Likely, BAL (Wk. 4: vs. Buf.): The hope with Likely was that he was going to emerge as the Ravens’ third target in the passing game behind Mark Andrews and Rashod Bateman, but through 3 weeks it’s been Devin Duvernay who has stepped up and earned that role. Likely is earning more targets than Duvernay, but Duvernay is on the field more and is getting targets in the red zone where it counts. Only Mark Andrews has more end zone targets on this team than Duvernay so far. Likely has zero. There is still some weekly upside here. Likely has been hovering around 45-50% route participation and is averaging just under 4 targets per game. There will be a week where he has a breakout performance eventually, but I wouldn’t count on it here against Buffalo. The Bills allow the 4^th-fewest TE points per game.

TE Jelani Woods, IND (Wk. 4: vs. Ten.): Woods made a big impact with his first targets of the season Sunday, finding the end zone twice against Kansas City, but it isn’t much different than OJ Howard scoring twice in week 1. The rookie hasn’t been on the field enough to be trusted yet in fantasy (he has 3 targets for the year), but he’s worth monitoring going forward. Woods’ route participation rate has gone from 7% to 17% to 27% in the first 3 weeks, and he may eventually supplant Kylen Granson as the team’s TE2.

TEs Jake Ferguson & Peyton Hendershot, DAL (Wk. 4: vs. Was.): It’s entirely possible that Dalton Schultz is out again in week 4, but neither Ferguson nor Hendershot dominated the TE work enough to be worth starting consideration this week if Schultz is unable to play. Ferguson played significantly more snaps, but both players garnered just 3 targets on Monday night and only Hendershot did anything with those targets, finishing with a 3-43 line. Both players are just desperation dart throws if Schultz is out again, and since they play at noon Sunday there are plenty of other fallback options if you want to wait on Schultz.

Deep League Sleepers, Stashes, and Cheap DFS Options:

QB Skylar Thompson, MIA (Wk. 4: @Cin.): You’ll need to keep an eye on the reports on the QB situation here. We saw starting Dolphins’ QB Tua Tagovailoa wobble and fall attempting to walk off a hit on Sunday, but the team allowed him to return to the game in the 2^nd half claiming he didn’t suffer a concussion, but rather had agitated a previous back injury. In any case, he’s listed as questionable for Thursday on a short week. The likeliest outcome if Tua sits would be for veteran Teddy Bridgewater to start in his place, but Head Coach Mike McDaniel is the type that is willing to think outside the box and Thompson played like a star in the preseason. The rookie completed 75% of his passes for 450 yards, 5 TDs, and zero interceptions in the exhibition season and offers a higher ceiling than Teddy B. The Bengals seem like a tough matchup on paper, allowing the 3^rd-fewest QB points per game, but they haven’t faced stiff competition. The 3 QBs they’ve faced so far – Mitch Trubisky, Cooper Rush and Joe Flacco – are the NFL equivalent of facing Glass Joe, Von Kaiser, and the 1^st Piston Honda. If Skylar gets the starting nod, he has real upside as a QB2 if you’re desperate for help at the position this week.

QB Kenny Pickett, PIT (Wk. 4: vs. NYJ): I mentioned Pickett in this section last week, and Mitch Trubisky didn’t do anything last week to dispel the idea that he should probably be benched for Pickett. If Mitch can’t right the ship against the lowly New York Jets’ defense, I don’t see how the Steelers go into a stretch with games against the Bills, Bucs, Dolphins, and Eagles with Trubisky still under center. In superflex leagues you should probably get ahead of the crowd and stash Pickett before he actually becomes the starter. It’s possible that a mid-game benching occurs this week if Trubisky struggles with the Jets.

RB Trestan Ebner, CHI (Wk. 4: @NYG): The Bears have played coy about the status of David Montgomery’s ankle injury, calling him day-to-day but refusing to definitively say they won’t put him on IR. I wouldn’t assume that he’s going to be out for multiple weeks, but for week 4 he’s probably on the wrong side of questionable. Khalil Herbert has been fantastic in his opportunities, but the Bears run too much for Herbert to handle all the work. I’d like Ebner a lot more if I trusted the Bears to throw enough that we could count on a few targets, but the Giants’ defense has been cooked by smaller, shiftier backs like Dontrell Hilliard (69 scrimmage yards and 2 TDs) and Tony Pollard (105 rushing yards), and they rank dead last in run defense DVOA. Ebner isn’t a great option in season-long leagues, but he has some big-play upside for DFS lineups. He costs just $2,000 in Showdown contests on DraftKings.

RB Brian Robinson Jr., WAS (Wk. 4: @Dal.): Robinson isn’t eligible to return from IR until week 5, but practice reports make it sound like he will be activated sooner rather than later. Robinson was slated to be the starting running back before getting about 2 weeks before the season opener, and I would expect him to be a major part of the backfield mix upon his return. The first 3 defenses the Commanders face after Robinson is eligible to return all rank 20^th or worse in run defense DVOA, and two of them are in the bottom-12 at limiting RB fantasy points. Robinson is worth a stash if an impatient manager dropped him while he was on IR.

WR Alec Pierce, IND (Wk. 4: vs. Ten.): Pierce returned in week 3 after missing the prior week with a concussion, and he was immediately a factor. He was in a route for less than 50% of Matt Ryan’s dropbacks, but he managed to turn 5 targets into a 3-61 line against the Chiefs. Michael Pittman is the WR1 here by a wide distance, but Pierce has a real chance to carve out a role as the WR2. His main competition, Parris Campbell, has been a non-factor through 3 weeks. I’d expect Pierce to see more playing time in week 3 against the Titans. Jonathan Taylor is battling a toe injury that has kept him out of practice this week, and the Titans allow the 4^th-most WR points per game. This is a spot where Pierce could have an unexpected splash game of 15+ PPR points.

WR Wan’Dale Robinson, NYG (Wk. 4: vs. Chi.): Wan’Dale has missed the last two weeks with injury and isn’t practicing as of Wednesday this week, but he should step into a high-volume role as soon as he’s able to get back onto the field. Kadarius Toney alternates between the coach’s doghouse and the injury report, Kenny Golladay may just be done for, and Sterling Shepard suffered a non-contact injury late Monday night that ended his season. Richie James and David Sills have held their own, but there is no one on this depth chart that is going to prevent Robinson from playing when healthy. The rookie opened the season as the starting slot receiver, and he should resume that role when he’s able to play. I’d be hesitant to fire him up this week against a Bears’ defense that has allowed the 10^th-fewest PPR points to slot receivers per Sports Info Solutions, but he shouldn’t be on the waiver wire in deeper leagues.

TE Greg Dulcich, DEN (Wk. 4: @LV): Like Robinson above, Dulcich was tracking to be a starter to open the season before finding himself on IR and is eligible to be activated in week 5. Albert Okwuegbunam hasn’t done anything to definitively take over the starting job, so I expect Dulcich to be worked in pretty quickly upon his return. The team said he’d be ready to go as soon as he was eligible when they put him on IR, and if that’s still the case he shouldn’t be sitting on waivers in deeper leagues, especially if they’re TE premium. The first opponent Dulcich could face is Indianapolis. The Colts have allowed the 3^rd-most TE points per game.

That’s all I’ve got for this week. Hopefully it helps you pull out a victory this week. Feel free to hit me up on Twitter (@Shawn_Foss) if you have any questions or want to yell at me about anything written above. Make sure to keep a close eye on the injury report throughout the week and do a final pre-game check to make sure you don’t start any inactive players. As always: Good luck, trust your gut and have fun. It’s just a game.